October
8, 2008 - LDK Solar (NYSE:LDK) reported this morning that it has raised
Q3 revenue guidance to a range between $530 million to $540 million, up from a
previous guidance range of $486 million to $496 million. It also said that its
shipments had a total capacity of 230MW to 240MW, up from a previously
forecasted 210MW to 220MW. And it has reached 1.2GW of production capacity by
the end of the quarter. This was its year-end goal, so it is clearly ahead of
schedule. None of this should be too surprising for investors paying attention
to LDK's results over the past couple of years. It has made a practice of
executing and beating Street expectations, and raising guidance. Nonetheless,
its stock has been sold off lately on broader market weakness and due to the
Street's reaction to Goldman Sach's downgrades of First Solar
(Nasdaq:FSLR) and SunPower (Nasdaq:SPWRA) yesterday, and related comments about
module oversupply. We think the stock has tremendously oversold at current
levels, and this morning's raise in guidance validates that sentiment.
We
now raising our forecast for LDK's FY2008 revenue to $1.8 billion, and
our income forecast to $324 million. At yesterday's closing price of
$19.32, the company is trading at less than 7x FY08 earnings, which, if we are
right about our estimates, will be up 131% on a Y/Y basis. The stock is trading
at 1.18x FY08 sales, which we forecast to be up 243%. These multiples do not
reflect fair value, in our opinion, and are the byproduct of the broader market
selloff, and yesterday's commentary from Goldman Sachs about oversupply
in the module space.
The
oversupply issue is old news, and it has been getting priced into solar stocks
now since January. The fact that Goldman Sachs decided to slash ratings on a
couple companies that we agree, were still holding pretty stiff premiums on a
relative basis, really shouldn't have bled over to impact LDK and several
other midstream companies that have already been sold off to levels which more
than factored this all in. But it did. We see this as unique opportunity to buy
LDK at a tremendous discount to what more reasonable multiples would put the
stock at.
At a 14x PE against 2008 earnings guidance, the stock would be trading at $66.
This is a 230% premium from current levels. The S&P average has
historically support a P/E multiple of 14x, and this is with the inclusion of a
broad number of businesses that don't show anywhere near the sequential
and year-over-year growth rate that LDK continues to demonstrate. So we think
this valuation and target is completely reasonable and defensible.
|